Help Choosing Trench Coat

[nj121]

I have been looking for a less expensive trench coat for my daily commute.

I walk around 2 mile a day for work from train station and i need something for both rain and cold weather (especially during windy day)

I have come across two coats which I like. I would appreciate if you guys can provide your views or any other suggestion in the same price range

London fog Bogart: Bogart Coat

Eddie Bauer Commuter Trench Coat: Commuter Coat

Thank you so much for your time

-R

 

[mensimageconsultant]

The London Fog looks okay (albeit in a color scheme that isn't very versatile), but its fabric is dubious. The Eddier Bauer looks boxy and too casual and not like a true trench coat. Budget, measurements, and so on, please? Maybe Brooks Brothers, for example, would have something.