I ordered a pair of the Grenson Rugby's from Chris at Bennie's. Gorgeous shoes, but they didn't fit. I normally wear a 9 or 9 1/2 and the pair I ordered was a 9C. It was too tight in the toe. Do you think a 9 1/2 C would be okay? It felt snug all the way around, but would this be helped by a 1/2 size larger at all? It hurt to send them back, but it would have hurt more to have worn them. What a conundrum.