Grenson Shoe Selection: Help out

[threeleggeddog]

Alright, so looking for some opinions here. I can get a pretty good deal on any of these Grensons.

http://www.bonobos.com/store/cat/shoes/dress_shoes

I'm trying to decide between the James/Stanley/Dylan Black. Drastically different looks, but my NICE shoe collection is pretty weak. I have a pair of Varvatos Saddle shoes and a bunch of Cole Haan oxfords/loafers. Does anyone have some opinions with regards to style/practicality?

 

[Schweino]

I would stay away from the new line of Grenson shoes, they are of low quality. I used to love Grenson shoes (not only the Rose line: I even have some of the old Rushden line which I like) but the quality has gone downhill it seems. I recently bought a tan brown Grenson Sharp and tan grain Dylan, but am not impressed by them. Especially the leather quality and overall finishing is disappointing (all made in India from cheap materials now I guess).

 

[threeleggeddog]

Good to know. Who would you recommend for a shoe similar in style and price to the tan Dylan?

 

[freedom_fries]



I would stay away from the new line of Grenson shoes, they are of low quality. I used to love Grenson shoes (not only the Rose line: I even have some of the old Rushden line which I like) but the quality has gone downhill it seems. I recently bought a tan brown Grenson Sharp and tan grain Dylan, but am not impressed by them. Especially the leather quality and overall finishing is disappointing (all made in India from cheap materials now I guess).

I somewhat disagree with this comment - I recently picked up some sharp boots and william brogues, and have been quite impressed with the overall quality and leather for the price.

That said, I didn't pay anything near what that website you've linked is asking, nor would I.

 

[threeleggeddog]

I think I decided on my initial question (I want a pair of Tan Brogues). Now I need to decide whether or not Grenson is really the brand to go to. I kind of want to rename this thread: "Best Tan Brogues for around $300"

Any suggestions?

 

[cioni2k]

I recently bought a pair of Grensons off Gilt (I assume the new line discussed previously). Garbage quality. Sent them back immediately. Will be staying away from Grenson in the future.

 

[cioni2k]

Oh, and to add, best shoes for ~$300? Off the shelf I say Allen Edmonds. Scour B/S Forums and you can find great shoes for $300 new.

 

[Kauai]

I bought several pairs of Grenson Masterpiece for Paul Stuart a few weeks ago. The Masterpiece line is no longer sold directly by Grenson, but it is similar in quality to Edward Green IMHO. If you are little flexible on style you should check out this SF Thread on a bunch of these shoes that have been closing out in the $140-$180 range. There have been two rounds of shoes already, and I have purchased and posted pictures in both rounds. FWIW I think you can't get a better deal than Grenson Masterpiece in the ~$150 range, that said my JL's are somewhat nicer in terms of fit and finish, but you would have to pay 10X more to get them. Ron is planning to add several hundred more pairs to his online store in the next couple of weeks.

http://www.styleforum.net/t/255994/psa-grenson-masterpiece-and-gravati-blowout#post_4681222

 

[Schweino]

I agree with poster above. Get the masterpiece ones or even the rose or old rushden line. Just avoid the current series (as seen on http://www.grenson.co.uk/shop?limit=all).

@freedom_fries: have you ever owned a pair of Grensons from before last year when Grenson was taken over by Tim Little? The difference in quality is huge imo and currently nowhere near acceptable for it's price range.

 

[countbaron]



I agree with poster above. Get the masterpiece ones or even the rose or old rushden line. Just avoid the current series (as seen on http://www.grenson.co.uk/shop?limit=all).

@freedom_fries: have you ever owned a pair of Grensons from before last year when Grenson was taken over by Tim Little? The difference in quality is huge imo and currently nowhere near acceptable for it's price range.

Who is this Little man you speak of??

 

[Newcomer]

Allen Edmonds Strands, imo

 

[sportin_life]

I have a pair of the Tylers. I think the quality is comparable to AE. It's not horrible but not great either. Leather is nothing to brag about, but decent. Construction feels solid to me so far. The last is definitely more sleek though and better suited for those with narrow feet.

I don't personally own any EG or Vass, nor Grenson Masterpiece. From the shoes I own, I've always felt my RL's have been the best bang for the buck (both the C&J and the Made in USA ones), especially since they can be had on sale.

 

[Schweino]



Who is this Little man you speak of??

http://www.drapersonline.com/news/f...e-buys-footwear-brand-grenson/5014839.article

 

[freedom_fries]



I agree with poster above. Get the masterpiece ones or even the rose or old rushden line. Just avoid the current series (as seen on http://www.grenson.co.uk/shop?limit=all).

@freedom_fries: have you ever owned a pair of Grensons from before last year when Grenson was taken over by Tim Little? The difference in quality is huge imo and currently nowhere near acceptable for it's price range.

no, the latest two pairs are the first. But from what I've seen they're each worth at least the 80 pounds I paid for them, particularly since i would never, for instance, pay a lot of money for blue suede brogue boots.

 

[sportin_life]

The current Grenson's often go on sale due to promotions. I grabbed my Tylers for around $125, which I thought was reasonable for beaters considering they aren't horrible.