Discussion in 'Classic Menswear' started by Claghorn, Jan 6, 2014.
How about with a solid blue vicuña Kent wang suit?
^Nope. Pair with a full-length chinchilla coat, blue vicuña homburg and ivory-handled cane.
Cane: check! Homburg: check! Coat: let me see what I can find on eBay
Don't forget to accessorize:
Appalling fail. That is not a full-length chinchilla. It's a full-length mink with a chinchilla collar. Strictly for small-timers.
A black wholecut is a great shoe option for business wear or also evening "formal" wear. I wouldn't consider them a novelty item at all. They are certainly as evening appropriate as a black captoe oxford. I don't know where the notion came from that wholecuts are from the new-school of fashion.
Indeed. A plain toe oxford was originally more appropriate for wearing with a worsted suit than a cap toe oxford, and a whole cut is a only a small step away from a plain toe oxford, so stop parroting Manton.
I do agree with him that a wholecut stands out more than a regular oxford in today's world, but for some people, like jfrater, that doesn't really matter much.
since you have half their stock in hand
which ones are 5, 6, and 7? Is one the air force blue japanese wool/silk? They also have two blue donegals apparently, old and new. Natural light shot of those three a bit closer?
Wow - I never thought I'd be getting these suggestions on StyleForum! Those watches make my Rolex look cheap! So much bling. I'm going to book into the dentist to get my front teeth replaced with gold to match.
All fantastic shoes.
Meh. GGs are plenty well made, and if one prefers a GG model of a Vass model there is no reason to go GG.
Not a single loser in the group.
5. Airforce blue with chevron: http://vandafineclothing.com/store/neckties/399-airforce-blue-chevron.html
6. Blue silk cashmere: http://vandafineclothing.com/store/neckties/580-blue-silk-cashmere-donegal.html
7. Navy olive plaid: http://vandafineclothing.com/store/neckties/236-navy-olive-plaid.html
Once the sun is fully up I'll take a better shot for you
I think a black wholecut can work fine with a suit as can something like a black monkstrap. Of course black oxfords are fine with a suit, but that goes without saying. If by putting "formal" in quotation marks, you are suggesting something like a dark navy or grey suit rather than black tie, then I think they're fine. With a dinner jacket, I'd say no.
I think the issue I have with wholecuts is due to them standing out a bit more and being a bit more unusual (I was using "novelty" more to address this point, though I believe oxfords have been regularly worn with formal clothing much longer than wholecuts so the other uses of the word still kind of work). The shoe looks like a plain toe oxford at first, but it isn't. It is a bit more "fashion-y" even if it's been around for awhile. I think it would be strange to wear a wholecut with an odd jacket and trousers due to its sleekness (of course this can be disregarded if you are fine wearing oxfords with odd jackets), so it basically turns into a non-oxford that can only be worn like an oxford. I just wouldn't know what to do with a pair of them or why I'd want them when I could get a pair of oxfords instead.
Add cordovan and a shoe in midnight blue instead of black and you get even stranger.
You've captured precisely the issue that I have with wholecuts. They do stand out more, which to me suggests that they may be less appropriate in the most formal contexts. At the same time, their sleekness seems to suggest that they belong with suits rather than odd jackets (to the extent one follows the oxfords with suits rule). I sort of get why someone would want a pair if they like variety or something that is a bit fun and fashionable, but I look at them and see a shoe that is never the superior option (plain toe oxford for dinner jacket is better, stitch cap or punch cap oxford for formal suits, derbys / monks for more casual suits and odd jackets, loafers with more casual fits). I understand that not everyone looks at building a wardrobe as an optimization exercise (I don't entirely, but there's enough there that I do).
JFrater definitely has a place in a massive shoe wardrobe for a pair of pretty much anything, though.
Incidentally, I think that adding a stitch or punch cap to a pair of plain toe oxfords is a much smaller modification than turning an oxford into a wholecut, both in terms of the structure of the shoe and its overall look.
IMO Whole cut oxfords > Cap toe/stitch cap/whatever cap for a sleek suit look all day and everyday. 365 days of the year and leap years
Whole cut suede oxfords. Now that's a different beast all together.
Yeah the Rubi squares are awesome. On my last trip to Naples I snagged a bunch of them.
Whole cuts are great with city suits...they are very formal. But Navy is kind of an odd color for a wholecut, given the formality of the style. Maybe consider having them re-painted black.
Separate names with a comma.