Discussion in 'Classic Menswear' started by Claghorn, Jan 6, 2014.
Didn't expect @PatrickR to have so many flannel shirts.
I have at least two shirts in each of the first five fabrics you linked.
I have the first three...from Luxire. They are good.
He's got a mean casual game.
+1 to navy pencil stripes on a white ground.
Is there a way to bookmark posts? For example, in the a few months I would love to come back to these shirt recommendations.
I'm loving the first # of a specific clothing items. They are so helpful especially with the specific examples. Thanks all for taking the time.
Ikea sells inexpensive wooden hangers.
I seem to remember this has been discussed before, but does anyone share my dislike for shirts where the stripes are thinner than those of the white ground? If so, is there a rational explanation?
Yeah,it was something along those lines, iirc. But then, the question remains: why are they not in good taste? Somehow I associate them with 'cheap', thought I know there are plenty of high end shirts with stripes like that too. Anyone who can shed some light on this?
Elio I share your dislike too but honestly I don't see any obvious reason for it. Symmetry on its own isn't a good argument as everyone here is a FIH advocate precisely because the knot isn't symmetrical. Symmetry for shirts but not ties?
Still, perhaps our current, group aesthetic gravitates towards symmetry or at least some constancy in repetition of any pattern: think of patterned ties. Is that why I dislike paisleys too? They can seem quite "asymmetric" (and loud). But cf. neats, dots, stripes which feel best when they are not irregular in pattern (IMO).
We should throw up some examples in the Lounge.
Maybe we are just conservative and post hoc justifying our tastes?
Amazingly useful @Claghorn .
Throw me in the other camp. My favorite striped shirts, the blue stripes are thinner than the white ground.
Those who would argue that asymmetrical stripes are in bad taste simply because they’re asymmetrical would need to explain why symmetry matters some times but not other times. The suit coat itself is asymmetrical in certain respects.
(1) The left side overlaps the right side and has buttonholes while the right side had buttons.
(2) Typically the jacket has a single breast pocket, on the left.
(3) Use of a pocket square exaggerates the asymmetry.
The bottom line for me is that the symmetry argument underestimates the complexity of human cognition. Yes, for lots of evolutionary reasons the brain is good at detecting visual symmetry (it correlates non-trivially with the presence of another organism). But humans are also intelligent agents who often seek interest and novelty. Asymmetry can be interesting—it attracts attention, especially when seen against a larger, more symmetrical field.
Let me be clear that I’m not offering an opinion on the tastefulness or otherwise of such stripes. I’m simply saying that the argument from symmetry doesn’t work.
Separate names with a comma.