Gaziano & Girling Appreciation & Shoe Appreciation Thread (including reviews, purchases, pictures)

[tim_horton]

OK, thank you. St James I is MUCH better IMO than the II. I did not know that they can make it MTO since I did not see on the website.

I have no idea quite frankly who decided and why to change the style. The peak heel counter is another change but that's not what ruined the shoe.

Yes, the SJ I is an option on the website under the MTO section.

Aside from the brogueing on the heel, what other changes did they make?

 

[sforum1]

Yes, the SJ I is an option on the website under the MTO section.

Aside from the brogueing on the heel, what other changes did they make?

They changed the "shape of the adelaide" in the front. Pay close attention, even though it's obvious.The first one below if St. James I. The base of the bottle formed is straight on the St. James II while on the St. James I is curved and the bottle overall narrower. Do you see it?

 

[tim_horton]

They changed the "shape of the adelaide" in the front. Pay close attention, even though it's obvious.The first one below if St. James I. The base of the bottle formed is straight on the St. James II while on the St. James I is curved and the bottle overall narrower. Do you see it?

I do, thanks for posting them. Definitely confirms my preference for the SJ I.
]

 

[Chowkin]

They changed the "shape of the adelaide" in the front. Pay close attention, even though it's obvious.The first one below if St. James I. The base of the bottle formed is straight on the St. James II while on the St. James I is curved and the bottle overall narrower. Do you see it?

I think the first pair is also St James II. The photo is taken from Leffot’s blog where, although the shoes are labeled as St James, you can definitely see the peaked counter:

Gaziano & Girling St. James Restock

The captoe oxford is a classic shoe that needs no introduction. Gaziano & Girling's St. James is an elegant and refined take on the captoe that stands out in its Vintage Cherry Calfskin. Pair with a navy or grey suit and you'll be the sharpest one in the room.TG73 Last, Vintage Cherry Calfskin

blog.leffot.com

The shoe in your second photo is the second iteration of St James II. G&G widen the bottom of the “U” to make the sides curvier, which they say lends a more bespoke feel.

Gaziano & Girling Appreciation & Shoe Appreciation Thread (including reviews, purchases, pictures)

Beautiful! Is that an MTO StJ-III in Vintage Cedar on TG73? Or Skoak's stock model from earlier?

www.styleforum.net

More photos showing the old vs new St James II:

Gaziano & Girling Appreciation & Shoe Appreciation Thread (including reviews, purchases, pictures)

ecwy congrats man they look good. Is the isham kudu batch all ready out? Or was this some different gmto? Could be partially out, or this could have been an MTO. I haven't received an email yet. I have not also, no email that is why I asked & thank you for feed back. Based on the...

www.styleforum.net

 

[iyorito]

:

 

[sforum1]

I think the first pair is also St James II. The photo is taken from Leffot’s blog where, although the shoes are labeled as St James, you can definitely see the peaked counter:

Gaziano & Girling St. James Restock

The captoe oxford is a classic shoe that needs no introduction. Gaziano & Girling's St. James is an elegant and refined take on the captoe that stands out in its Vintage Cherry Calfskin. Pair with a navy or grey suit and you'll be the sharpest one in the room.TG73 Last, Vintage Cherry Calfskin

blog.leffot.com

The shoe in your second photo is the second iteration of St James II. G&G widen the bottom of the “U” to make the sides curvier, which they say lends a more bespoke feel.

Gaziano & Girling Appreciation & Shoe Appreciation Thread (including reviews, purchases, pictures)

Beautiful! Is that an MTO StJ-III in Vintage Cedar on TG73? Or Skoak's stock model from earlier?

www.styleforum.net

More photos showing the old vs new St James II:

Gaziano & Girling Appreciation & Shoe Appreciation Thread (including reviews, purchases, pictures)

ecwy congrats man they look good. Is the isham kudu batch all ready out? Or was this some different gmto? Could be partially out, or this could have been an MTO. I haven't received an email yet. I have not also, no email that is why I asked & thank you for feed back. Based on the...

www.styleforum.net

You are absolutely correct. There is an in-between version that had the peaked counter but the face was still the same as St James I. I was just focusing on the 'other difference', besides the peaked counter, between St.James I and St. James II as people know it today.

 

[iyorito]

They changed the "shape of the adelaide" in the front. Pay close attention, even though it's obvious.The first one below if St. James I. The base of the bottle formed is straight on the St. James II while on the St. James I is curved and the bottle overall narrower. Do you see it?

The picture above is St.James1 v1.0. Hence, the vamp design is a bit rounded. The pattern of this is no longer around. v1.0 St.James' cannot be ordered anymore. To avoid confusion at the factory, sadly, all the v1.0 patterns for St.James 1 and 2 had been thrown away.

The factory only has the below, 2.0 patterns, for St.James 1 and 2. The only difference is the peak on the heel cap.

St.James v1.0 and Tavistock are the only models that had been phased out completely.

 

[sforum1]

The picture above is St.James1 v1.0. Hence, the vamp design is a bit rounded. The pattern of this is no longer around. v1.0 St.James' cannot be ordered anymore. To avoid confusion at the factory, sadly, all the v1.0 patterns for St.James 1 and 2 had been thrown away.

The factory only has the below, 2.0 patterns, for St.James 1 and 2. The only difference is the peak on the heel cap.

St.James v1.0 and Tavistock are the only models that had been phased out completely.

Wow, thank you. I was actually about to send an email to G&G now to ask them after the member above said that he ordered it. During this whole time I was under the impression that it was not possible to order it, but this discussion gave me some renewed hopes. I was checking the MTO page and indeed, there is a model that's labeled as St. James Vs another that is labeled as St. James II. But by looking at the pics the vamp area is the same. So I thought either they had the wrong pic or they had the wrong name and they meant to say St. James II.

So what you said right now makes sense.

I think St. James II's pattern looks overexaggerated. Something about it that I did not like from day one. V1 seems more balanced.

 

[Easily Amused]

Westbury wholecuts (I need to find replacement laces). The Sinatra gets the most love in this department, though I find the raised handstitching around the throat of the Westbury more pleasing than the plain lines of the other.

 

[saurabh]

G&G Arrans in Chestnut Kudo!!

 

[sforum1]

Westbury wholecuts (I need to find replacement laces). The Sinatra gets the most love in this department, though I find the raised handstitching around the throat of the Westbury more pleasing than the plain lines of the other.

View attachment 1485423View attachment 1485424

I'm interested more in the pant. Post link, if one exists.

 

[Easily Amused]

I'm interested more in the pant. Post link, if one exists.

Rota mid-grey crisp weave trousers, from NMWA.

 

[sforum1]

Rota mid-grey crisp weave trousers, from NMWA.

I knew it that it would be something up there; was clearly hoping it would be a little cheaper.

I already own 2 pairs and Rota are the best by far. What other brands do you own that you like as much overall or even more than Rota? I would like to try something else next time I spend $500 on pants. I own Zegna and RLPL and, while they are good, Rota is one (or two?) step above.

Also, don't get me wrong. The shoes are amazing too and the fit especially. The overall combo one of the best I've seen in a long time.

 

[thesartorialistbanker]

@saurabh these are the most perfect fall boots and the pairing with brown cords is excellent

 

[Easily Amused]

I knew it that it would be something up there; was clearly hoping it would be a little cheaper.

I already own 2 pairs and Rota are the best by far. What other brands do you own that you like as much overall or even more than Rota? I would like to try something else next time I spend $500 on pants. I own Zegna and RLPL and, while they are good, Rota is one (or two?) step above.

Also, don't get me wrong. The shoes are amazing too and the fit especially. The overall combo one of the best I've seen in a long time.

All the Rotas I've purchased (including these) were either on sale or I won through LuxeSwap eBay auctions. I have mix of trouser makers/brands, and actually don't have a favorite. Bill's Khaki's, SuitSupply, Eidos, Theory, and a single pair of Billy Reid are in my regular mix. A few of these I purchased 10-15 years ago; they still fit and are still in good shape, thankfully.