An Acute Style
Distinguished Member
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2011
- Messages
- 7,717
- Reaction score
- 56,596
Thanks for the votes, gents.
STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.
Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.
Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!
Styleforum is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
AAS the standout this week IMO. The shirt itself was considerably less garish than most but it actually made sense in the context of the fit.
Most of the other shirts seemed like afterthoughts.
Clapeyron was my runner-up more because everything fit really well.
I do dislike almost all of the shirts in this thread but that wasn't my criticism.
Most of them bore no relation to the rest of the outfits. So nearly all of these fits look like what you'd expect when asking normally traditionally(ish) dressed guys to wear a fun shirt. You get pretty normal outfits + a... noticeable... shirt.
Where AAS succeeded (IMO) is that a cotton or linen blazer + khakis makes sense with a summery green shirt. A navy worsted wouldn't be nearly as harmonious.
And it helps that AAS, as I mentioned before, has a dope roll on that collar.
I do dislike almost all of the shirts in this thread but that wasn't my criticism.
Most of them bore no relation to the rest of the outfits. So nearly all of these fits look like what you'd expect when asking normally traditionally(ish) dressed guys to wear a fun shirt. You get pretty normal outfits + a... noticeable... shirt.
Where AAS succeeded (IMO) is that a cotton or linen blazer + khakis makes sense with a summery green shirt. A navy worsted wouldn't be nearly as harmonious.
And it helps that AAS, as I mentioned before, has a dope roll on that collar.
I'd swear I have seen polls open through Monday on some other challenges - isn't that the way it is?
i have a strong feeling Ts sudden surge was due to clapeys x-posting a link to the voting in SWD. id bet on it.
I do dislike almost all of the shirts in this thread but that wasn't my criticism.
Most of them bore no relation to the rest of the outfits. So nearly all of these fits look like what you'd expect when asking normally traditionally(ish) dressed guys to wear a fun shirt. You get pretty normal outfits + a... noticeable... shirt.
Where AAS succeeded (IMO) is that a cotton or linen blazer + khakis makes sense with a summery green shirt. A navy worsted wouldn't be nearly as harmonious.
And it helps that AAS, as I mentioned before, has a dope roll on that collar.
I knew this was going to happen. As soon as people started posting about ties I sensed failure. While my example may not be the most tasteful or the best-executed, there was no way I was going to try to mix a "bold" shirt with a tie or any sort of traditional rig. Hence the slubby jacket and faded jeans.
All that said, I think a lot of "pulling off" bold items comes from the wearer's confidence. I get the feeling close to everyone who posted in here had some reservations about wearing what they wore and/or had to think about their execution a lot. That kind of over-thinking and premeditation shines through when you are wearing something bold. And so you can easily differentiate between someone nonchalantly saying FU vs. someone trying to fit a square peg in a round hole.
I can speak only for myself, but I didn't find my shirt to be that bold, especially in the context of an otherwise sober combination. Essentially, I replaced a solid, light-blue shirt with a solid, light-green shirt. Unconventional, maybe, but hardly bold.
Since I'm not creative enough to wear an unusual color shirt, here are IMO a couple good examples--