lawyerdad
Lying Dog-faced Pony Soldier
- Joined
- Mar 10, 2006
- Messages
- 27,006
- Reaction score
- 17,142
If you haven't heard it used as sarcasm, how have you heard it used? What is evident in proNUNciation to some people is not always evident to others.Originally Posted by Britalian
Is not the 'abbreviation' you refer to the obvious (after some consideration) meaning of the phrase? Why would someone use the particular words used in this phrase to mean the opposite of the established phrase 'I couldn't care less'?
The bit in the middle was, I expect, used by Mr Pinker to try to represent the contrasting phrases and their pronunciation, as you rightly stated.
I can see how an interpretation that you support (ie. that it's been misheard and corrupted by certain people) stands up, but surely you can also see the capacity for the interpretation I quoted too. No?
Believe me, if you give the phrase the correct inflexion/inflection, you can produce a sarcastic tone; similarly, you can not produce such a tone and deliver as flatly as you have no doubt heard it spoken.
Both explanations are rational. I'm inclined, however, to agree with rdawson. I'm confident that if I had pointed out the apparent incongruity in the phrase "I could care less" to everyone I hear utter that phrase, at least 90% would reply with a befuddled stare; I would be pleasantly surprised if someone were to reply that they fully understood the literal import of their words but had been speaking sarcastically.