Hello All, I've been eyeing this http://www.ctshirts.com/Charcoal-covert-coat?q=usddefault||OC007DGY|||||||||||| covert coat from Charles Tyrwhitt as a fall/spring coat to wear over my suit/sport coat, and now that I can get it on sale I wonder if this is appropriate for wearing in the city. I recall that the covert coat was a hunting and riding jacket typically associated with the country. Since I live in NYC, what type of impression would this give? (I read somewhere of someone comparing this type of coat to what a doorman wears) What alternatives could I find for the same price point? My other question was whether I should get this http://www.ctshirts.com/men's-outer...-overcoat?q=usddefault||OC036CHA||||||||||||| coat for winter or keep my current coat. It's a Joseph Abboud 90% Wool/10% Cash Charcoal, in the same length except no breast pockt, slanted side pockets, and a subtle black diagonal pattern. I like the coat but the lining is falling apart. My tailor can replace it but I wonder if it's worth it, seeing that it may not be formal enough to wear with a suit. I'm about 5'8" 180lbs, wide athletic build with short lower body to torso ratio Thank You all.