Discussion in 'Classic Menswear' started by SuitedDx, Nov 16, 2011.
I agree with you that the price to quality ratio is good even with the upcharge.
Um, are you sure there's an SF promo that applies to the AS Exclusive shoes (from afinepair)?
Yes when I got a price from AFPS, it included the 10% SF discount
This feels like a total no-brainer. C&J. Gorgeous colour, classic last. I want it.
No-brainer? I don't see major differences in lasts. This C&J is benchgrade while the AS is in the handgrade level. Note that OP can choose his own color too, so it's not the comparison point.
Didn't know about the colour. CJ is round, AS is chisel toed. It also looks like maybe CJ has a double sole, which Ive recently been into.
Cottesmore has a double sole
I'd go C & J, nicer shape in the lower ankle
They have a jodhpur boot on the page I pointed to. It seems to be a basic template in which many of the features are adjustable. So, for example, if you don't like the toe shape pictured, you can select something else. Since they're relatively cheap, it might be a fun experiment.
BTW, One of the problems I have with C&J is that virtually all their boots come in one width -- damn wide. They make very nice stuff but fit is not their strong point.
Just resurecting an old thread, as I've been having this exact quandry today.
I love C&J, they are one of my favourite brands, but currently I am swaying towards the Alfred Sargent's.
They are quite sleek and I think would look great with trousers or jeans. That's a beautiful colour too with more burnishing, and the sole is rather pleasing to look at too!
I think the AS Alex belong to the Exclusive range, which is totally different to their Handgrade range. Anyway, I prefer the AS Alex to C&J Cottesmore, because as Gdot said, it's sleeker in shape and dressier. Regarding to the color, I prefer the Oak tanned color of the AS because it is easier to match with dress pants or jeans (navy, gray or any shade of brown) while the C&J is much more suitable with blue jeans.
P/S: Sorry for my terrible English
agreed here. 341 is a great last but didnt look sleek enough for a plain toe jodhpur
Separate names with a comma.