Thrift Vader
Forum Mechanic
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2014
- Messages
- 13,314
- Reaction score
- 12,050
i don't want you guys to think i consider Evo's and WRX's as inferior. i don't, at least not from a performance standpoint.
the reason i wouldn't pick them over a sports coupe from the same era is (a) i prefer coupes, (b) the 'econoboxes' they are based on are inherently compromised from a features/fit and finish standpoint, and (c) i don't like the way they look. but none of those are performance related reasons.
i found the Evo to be uncomfortable af, cheap feeling inside and out, and (subjectively, imo) ugly. with that out of the way, its steering was as sharp as any Porsche's, the grabby acceleration and cornering of the 4WD was as fun as hell, and it made lots of fun turbo noises. it's a serious performance machine, and no - i don't think we'll ever see anything like it again. well, when they eventually cancel the STi.
@HRoi i apologize if you think i accused you personally of being ignorant. but i did question your experience with the cars in question. myself i am lacking, which is why the review exchange would be fun.
we can agree, that the Evo's are plastic inside. (have seen a few) and? often set to "raw".
so while this will read as biased, i'm writing it anyway.
the coupe of the era could be the 350/370Z. they have all the tools. or the Miata Hardtops.
if you have the coin? the GTR's.
but? The fit and finish is woeful.
****, it was better in the 80's.
But you don't know the Subaru top tier. the top Legacy's shame BMW, or Audi. in options, and comfort. with a focus on the seats. and controls. (drive a GTB E-Tune for 2 years)
To be honest? Mrs V's Sti Forester seems rather spartan. but, what matters, is quality. i do hate the radio though. no reception. what you do get, is good seats, the MOMO wheel from the Sti WRX, and what is essentially a WRX lifted wagon. it's a stupidly good car.
one thing, it has squeaks. legacy's do not have squeaks.
not all Subies can fit in the one slot. the Forester is robust, the Legacy luxurious.
but the WRX STi? is a different animal.
aside from the obvious, -the mechanical craziness. on the inside? you have factory Recaro seats, covered in Alcantara,perforated leather, and cloth. with embroidered logo's and contrasting stitching. controls from Momo, and Nardi. and. THE cup holder. (Trust me)
inside an STi is a much nicer place to be than in an Evo.
with no squeaks.
so i warn against putting them in the same boat. they are very different.
IMHO Evo's are inferior. comfort wise, and in reliability. they break. often.
an STi is the pride of the company. not an offshoot.
Last edited: