STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.
Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.
Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!
Styleforum is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
I've tried on a few CCP scarstitches, in CORS, ROOLS, and something else. All comfortable Don't be such a bunch of babies. Though, the guy at l'Eclaireur was pretty surprised that I could wear a 8 lb jacket and feel completely at ease, so, ymmv (and it depends on what you are used to.) The CORS seemed plenty soft to me, especially for horse. I think that I'd actually possibly prefer the heavier, old, HOIL.My high neck is super comfortable. The scarstitch is pretty comfortable too
The fencing jacket IS uncomfortable though: armholes are ridiculously small and high
Also, the problem may be that some of the leathers were/are very thick/stiff. The newer CORS batches have been pretty soft though (at least the veg-tanned ones), and bison is soft, the thinner kangaroo (ROOLS) as well.
It's more on the cut rather than the weight of the leather. You're a pull up guy and I'm guessing your lats are quite wide. I don't think you'll feel comfortable in a fencing jacket. I think the Scarstitich is the most forgiving out of the 3.
HOIL is not available anymore and I don't think it is much heavier than the CORS. Rather, I think it is only stiffer due to a different method of treatment that was used before. It's just the recent CORS are veg tanned that's why I think it is softer.
I've found white tanned leather to be stiff and veg/slow tanned to be soft.
From my limited experience, I agree - HOIL not necessarily any thicker. And it's definitely not a weight of the leather thing, CCP usually has a pretty unforgiving cut, especially in the shoulders and arms. Scarstitch was fine until I started moving, but there's no way I could ride a train in one with my hands above
my head.