I have gone back and forth over this for almost the entire weekend now, and am no closer to deciding. My partner can't decide either - she likes them both as well! The shoe will be mostly worn with navy suits, with the occasional mid-grey suit. It will almost certainly be worn to some social events, though it will be doing work duty about 65% of the time. So it's time to turn to the forum - which one? The Belgrave, or the Audley? Both are on the same (337) C&J last, but the Audley (dark brown) is a little darker than the Belgrave (chestnut). Thanks all! PS: please check out the B&S thread in my sig! vs.