Brady vs. Manning: The Final Battle

[edinatlanta]

The population at large is never wrong. Voat now and settle this forever.

 

[dcg]

At football?

 

[mordecai]

I voted *

 

[Slopho]

Originally Posted by dcg

At football?

I voted before seeing this question.

 

[Matt]

Hathaway.

 

[kwilkinson]

Manning, at everything EXCEPT getting slammin' hotties. But, football, charity/philanthropy, commercials, etc, and it's Manning.

 

[mordecai]

poor eli

i bet peyton always gets the big piece of steak

 

[Douglas]

Originally Posted by mharwitt

poor eli

i bet peyton always gets the big piece of steak

haha, that is funny...

...though Eli can buy as many f*cking steaks as he wants to, and has as many rings. I'd say he has a better shot of finishing with more.

 

[edinatlanta]

I'm discounting Kwilk's voat due to bias so the real total is 85% for Brady.

 

[kwilkinson]

Originally Posted by edinatlanta

I'm discounting Kwilk's voat due to bias so the real total is 85% for Brady.
Are you going to discount all the Patriot fanboys too? God knows there are a lot more of them on this site than colts fans.

 

[dcg]

I cannot vote until my question is addressed. If we are talking only about football, then it's Brady. For total entertainment value it is Peyton.

Peyton:
+Basically his own offensive coordinator
+Never gets injured
+Awesome commercials
-Has a very annoying younger brother
-Not great in the playoffs
-Has the benefit of playing in a dome with great skill position players

Brady:
+More rings
+Hotter wife
+Over his career has had much less talent at skill positions than Peyton
-Bad commercials
-Has been injured
-Spygate!!111

 

[mordecai]

it's so satisfying to see Brady get sacked. therefore, manning wins

 

[clubbyjones]

Originally Posted by mharwitt

it's so satisfying to see what Brady sacked. therefore, manning loses

fixed.

 

[LawrenceMD]

Originally Posted by mharwitt

it's so satisfying to see Brady's ball sac..

but farve's ******** was nice too

dude WTF?

 

[mordecai]

LOL