Both are really nice. In the oxford I like the way everything matches, the grain and reg. leather in the laces area matches the wt / vamp area. all brogue lines and curves are almost perfectly paralel, it's very pleasant visually, my wingtip is not like that, never seen a wingtip like that. That made sense?, maybe I need help here, again, sorry for my bad shoe vocabulary, DWFII would hate to read this.