I'm having trouble pairing this Banana Republic dress shirt (white with somewhat-subtle light olive green pinstripes) with a tie. I have a green/gray plaid tie but seems like too much "green." Any suggestions? Thanks fellas. I think, given the neutral color, finding a similar color tone is going to be more important than finding a specific color to match— hence the "too green"-ness of your other tie. Dark navy would probably be safest, but other dark, solid colors would be a safe bet. A tie with a darker olive-ish base and a distinct accent color in dots or some other pattern might work well, too (or vice versa, with an olive accent to a darker base).