Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread - reviews, pictures, sizing, etc...

[lemmywinks]

What are the bare essentials I should have to care for my Walnut Strands? What's good polish?

 

[MarioImpemba]

Leeds today.

 

[norite]

Does anybody know what the difference between the Macneil Black Calf and the Macneil Black Custom Calf is? I saw both listed on the list provided by Shoebank but I have not a clue what the differences are. However, the customs were $100 more than the non-customs.

Also, when I emailed Shoebank for an updated list on seconds, they also listed some Closeouts. Are the Closeouts seconds as well or are they firsts that they are trying to get rid of?

 

[charliebrown2]

Has anyone seen which styles will be on sale at Nordstrom at the end of the month?

AE Park Avenue (Black only), $220
AE McTavish $197
AE Strand $220
AE Lasalle $200
AE Parkway $220
and more...

Source: http://slickdeals.net/f/4868844-Allen-Edmonds-men-s-dress-shoes-35-off-Nordstrom-Anniversary-Sale

Sale looks active for Nordstrom cardholders. Non-members...7/20. Don't know if I can wait that long. Interested in the mctavish myself

 

[SuitedDx]



Does anybody know what the difference between the Macneil Black Calf and the Macneil Black Custom Calf is? I saw both listed on the list provided by Shoebank but I have not a clue what the differences are. However, the customs were $100 more than the non-customs.

Also, when I emailed Shoebank for an updated list on seconds, they also listed some Closeouts. Are the Closeouts seconds as well or are they firsts that they are trying to get rid of?

Others can correct me if I am wrong but I believe "custom" calf is the sanded shiny finish on calf similar to Church's binder leather (which other term 'corrected' grain), not sure though.

 

[facet]



I need some polish advice.

I have recently acquired the Jefferson and the Flatiron.  Both in Walnut.  These are my first AE shoes in walnut and I am not sure which polish is best.  I have seen the AE walnut creme and without applying it, the color just doesn't look right to me.  Any better options out there?

I just got the Jefferson as well (love it) and have just been using their standard walnut polish on it, which I also used on my Augustas before I sold them. I also have neutral shoe cream that I use on occasion. So far, I haven't had any problems.

 

[SouthNarc]



I need some polish advice.

I have recently acquired the Jefferson and the Flatiron.  Both in Walnut.  These are my first AE shoes in walnut and I am not sure which polish is best.  I have seen the AE walnut creme and without applying it, the color just doesn't look right to me.  Any better options out there?

db I use Saphir exclusively. Creme for color and wax for shine/protection. For my Rutledges in AEs "Burnished" variation of Walnut, I went with Saphir Med. Brown creme and wax. For my Strands which are just the regular Walnut color I use Saphir Light Brown creme and wax, which actually seems to be a better color match than AEs own product.

 

[fiestaplatypus]

So, I just received my pair of Rutledge 2nd's and sadly, I'm contemplating a return. The shoes are fantastic looking overall, but there is something about the toebox areas on each that just doesn't look right to me. The rectangular discolorations have a slight indent to them. Anyone have an idea what could have caused this? Could polishing help minimize the visibility of the flaw?

I'm usually not one to take issue with the condition of the seconds I receive, but this will probably bother me a bit, since it's on the most visible portion of the shoe.

 

[ddsg]

Can anyone with a pair of walnut jefferson's post a picture? There are very few non product shots out and the color and sheen of the leather seems to vary a good deal...

 

[wigglr]

So, I just received my pair of Rutledge 2nd's and sadly, I'm contemplating a return. The shoes are fantastic looking overall, but there is something about the toebox areas on each that just doesn't look right to me. The rectangular discolorations have a slight indent to them. Anyone have an idea what could have caused this? Could polishing help minimize the visibility of the flaw?
I'm usually not one to take issue with the condition of the seconds I receive, but this will probably bother me a bit, since it's on the most visible portion of the shoe.

What size are they?

 

[JubeiSpiegel]

For your consideration, the Parkway, new AE shoe on the new 333 last:







This is the mysterious shoe also on sale for the Nordstrom Anniversary sale. It's a nice sleek looking mock toe, I think I'm picking this one up.

 

[tsekh]



So, I just received my pair of Rutledge 2nd's and sadly, I'm contemplating a return. The shoes are fantastic looking overall, but there is something about the toebox areas on each that just doesn't look right to me. The rectangular discolorations have a slight indent to them. Anyone have an idea what could have caused this? Could polishing help minimize the visibility of the flaw?
I'm usually not one to take issue with the condition of the seconds I receive, but this will probably bother me a bit, since it's on the most visible portion of the shoe.

Yea, the discoloration of the captoe looks weird. Any other noticeable flaws on it?

I'm contemplating getting a pair of Dalton seconds. But haven't ordered AE seconds before, not really sure what to expect.

 

[sportin_life]



Yea, the discoloration of the captoe looks weird. Any other noticeable flaws on it?
I'm contemplating getting a pair of Dalton seconds. But haven't ordered AE seconds before, not really sure what to expect.

I own several pairs of AE seconds. From my experience, in most cases there is no noticeable defect. In the worst case so far, there was some mild splitting on a small part of the seam but it did not affect the structural integrity of the shoe.

In general, I favor buying seconds way over considering used shoes. Also, the defects on the seconds tend to be minor compared to ebay "new with defect" ones (in which case I've seen ripped leather... seriously).

However, when AE's go on sale (like the Nordstrom sale coming up), firsts on sale is the way to go, considering the price difference for firsts on sale and seconds is minimal at that point. Speaking of which, time to grab another pair of strands and maybe mctavishes!

 

[PhiPsi32]

Call customer service and ask them if they will refinish the shoes or at least give you a discount on refinishing.

 

[reydogg23]

JubeiSpiegel - Those look great. Thanks for sharing I know most of us have been wondering what the Parkway looked like.