I've found that kennilworth runs slightly large. My other shoes in the 5-65 last (pa and fifth ave) fit like a glove in ten D, while the kenilworth is too long. I like the shoe, but the 9.5 is too small. Haven't yet tried a ten narrow or any other combinations like that. You might want to try an insert or something to take up a little bit of the space tho if you plan to keep them.