Heres the thing... If you can find a pair of burgundy shell seconds at Jville or elsewhere, jump on them before you get something else. I am sure the fine folks here can direct you to all the places you may find the seconds. If they are not available, you should go with Brown or Bourbon. You aren't going to go wrong with any color. You can always get another pair down the road. Keep in mind that these are more than a 1 season boot. These may be a 20+ year boot with the proper care. Ps. Any pair of shoes/boots will develop a patina and change some color over the time you have them. Best of luck.