Quote:I have two pairs of Ashtons and a pair of Scottsdales. I found the Benton/Ashton from the 8-678 last to fit me slightly better than the 1511G last shoes when using my normal custom orthotic. When I tried on the Ashton and the Winterpark in the store in 13d with my custom orthotic in place and the insole removed, the Ashton fit better. The Winterpark pinched my toes and seemed to have a more narrow fit over all. The SA assured me that the Scottsdale being a loafer would have a wider toe box so I ordered a pair. I am still breaking in the Scottsdale at home but I am using my slimmer custom sport orthotic for it. Prior to picking up AE shoes this year I was wearing 13e new balance walking shoes as they fit my custom orthotic the best. Are you interested in the orthotic line in hopes that they accomodate a wider foot better, or are you also using custom/other insoles?