STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.
Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.
Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!
Discussion in 'Classic Menswear' started by Mild Mannered, Sep 27, 2009.
I couldn't justify $345 for purple suede shoes... def would've paid $199.
I already own the Walnut McAllisters... I can't get myself to get a 2nd model of the same shoe in another color. Only exception would be the Park Avenues... I have them in black but am looking for a sale on the merlot/burgundy (whatever exact color it is in).
The smell of a brand-new AE leather sole is fantastic...
I can't wait to get mine. Hopefully, they'll be waiting for me tonight.
After looking at those photos I had to go thumbs-up Al's comment. Y'all are some seriously lucky goons.
For all those that got the gorgeous Townley's, be jealous of my 15 year old AE Margates!!
Actually, I recently gave them the Saphir strip down, Reno, and glacage treatment. They look pretty good now.
I also have a legitimate question: the Margates are on the 3 last (same as MacNeil), if I get the MacNeil in the same size, will it fit the same? Is there a noticeable difference between shell fit and calf fit?
Thanks in advance, gentlemen.
MacNeils are actually on the 7 last. The Broadstreets are on the old 3 last. I find the Mac Neil a little more roomy than the Broadstreet in the same size. Granted, this may be because the Broadstreet is a balmoral, while the MacNeil is a blucher.
Agreed. Very jealous these were only D width. My big feet (12 EEE) get in the way sometimes. Just got notice that my dark brown shell Dundees shipped. Supposedly the same color, so hopefully soon I have another color comparison shot.
The Margates are on the 7-Last as well. I assume he just misspoke. The fit comparison between the 3-73 last and the 7-97 last is quite a substantial difference, though. For what it's worth, I have the opposite experience. My 3-73 lasted shoes are significantly roomier than my 7-97 lasted ones.
Yes, they are on the 7, and yes I did mis-type.
Same question though - Will there be any difference in fit between shell and calf shoes on the 7 last? These Margates are 9.5E and fit very well.
Here are my AE 5ths with the encouraged high shine toe. I really like the effect so much better than before. I wasn't having much success but then added a little water and bang. I will soon be posting my before and after where I sanded the edge to remove blotchy dressing then reapplied, stand by for those pics and story.
If these are all full price, I would go with the two shoes rather than one shell and hope for a deal on the shell. I honestly wouldn't pay full price for any of the shoes though, given that there are seconds and sales on firsts. You may want to take a different approach though.
Unboxing a pair of shell shoes is even better.
So I just got my first pair of AEs! A waxed black leather McTavish for $189 (seconds) from the Freeport store. If I wanted to give the toes a bit of shine (while carefully avoiding the contrast stitching), what would all recommend? I'm planning on wearing these to a casual outdoor wedding with either my charcoal or light grey suit.
ummm, I think I may do exactly that. The merlot McAllisters have been shipped and will be on my doorstep on Friday (just in time for my birthday present).
I debated incessantly over the merlot v walnut but since I already have the Bourbon Strand I needed to get a "classic". Don't get much more classic than the Merlot McAllisters except for the PA's.
I'll probably end up with walnut McAllisters too just because they are drop-dead gorgeous, albeit not as versatile as the merlot.
You seem to be in the same situation as me; just starting to build a solid rotation so I empathize with your consternation over styles/colors. Right now I have burgundy PA and bourbon Strand. Merlot Mac's come Friday and then I'll probably add a black pair before I can justify the walnut Mac's.
Same here. A few weeks back I picked up a pair of walnut McAllister because I just thought they were awesome looking. Once I saw that they went on sale I ordered a pair of the same in merlot. The walnut is very flashy and in the right situation they are perfect and I've received many positive comments thus far. However, I figured the merlot was classic and versatile and probably means I don't need a darker brown or bourbon but we'll see. They should arrive soon. Now I'm debating a nice pair of black shoes. I like the Strand in black and while I know many people may find that shoe useless (just get a black plain cap-toe like the PA, they say) I like the Strand in black and find the PA boring. But, that's down the road...
As an aside... I went back to the same shop where I picked up the walnuts only a few weeks prior and before I could even ask he credited me the difference between what I paid and the new sale price since I had purchased them so recently. Great service!
Separate names with a comma.