Actually got fitted today at a store... What a world of difference! I wear anywhere from an 11 to 11.5 in most shoes, but it turns out I'm just a modest 9.5D in Allen Edmonds, and I'm guessing most other shoes. If Nordstrom was carrying the Strand in 9.5 I must have gotten those, but I got a 10D, which fits great, but still has the slight roominess I'm used to. You know how as a kid all your shoes are bought slightly bigger because your feet will grow eventually? Yep. So this is a huge notice to everyone who is just starting to step up their dress shoe game... GET FITTED!! A well-fitted pair of dress shoes is actually really comfortable to walk in. I almost want to get another pair of Allen Edmonds strictly for casual wear with jeans but it's just really not my style at the moment.