Thanks for the pictures. Nice looking captoe collection! I think I will just stick with what I said above and handle it on a case-by-case basis (fortunately for my size, the placement is fine with me). For what it's worth, the PA's may actually have been my favorites in your group. I know I'm as subjective in my tastes as everyone else, but that quintessential American look generally wins me over. I may take an Alden captoe on the Aberdeen or Hampton over a PA, but the funny thing is, I see versions of those where the cap seems to be in a similarly placed position and people don't really seem to criticize Alden for theirs.