Which of these would you go with for wear with slim, dark jeans and a blazer? I like the extra broguing of the McAllister near the tongue (see top view), but I feel the lacing style of the Player's shoe is a bit more casual and might work better with jeans: McAllister - more formal lacing I think what I like most is this extra broguing because is make the wingtip feel less long & awkward looking from the top view. (Wingtips always have this long, torpedo like shape that I think looks great from the sides, but not so much from the top. Anyone else agree?) I'm not a big fan of the closed lacing, but I suppose people wear Strands with jeans all the time and those are balmorals. vs. Nordstrom (AE) Player's shoe - blucher Obviously they are pretty similar. Thoughts?