AE Greenwich and Mahattan fit questions

[Trojanman74]

so with AE closing out these two styles i might have my girlfriend make one of these two shoes my valentine day's present. what i would like is someone who owns either to give me their opinion of the shoe please. thank you kindly

edit just read the thread on the greenwich and everyone hates it, now just for the manhattan

 

[jmix1]

I'm not a big fan of the Manhattan. If you want a wholecut, why not go with the Westgate, which you should still be able to find online even if not directly from AE. I have the Westgates in cognac and wear them all the time with everything from jeans to navy suits.

 

[AnGeLiCbOrIs]

My Manhattan fits very well and true to size. They are really nice in saddle brown - Much better than in pictures.

The Greenwich is kinda fugly.