Why the Four-in-hand is always better than the windsor knot:
The windsor looks so much better in this example. Much cleaner and more rounded. I don't like when ties are creased like that in the middle. Looks cheap/cheesy to me (-_-)
The half windsor is the prettiest of the all.
Might even be mistaken for a HW with how shit the produced knot is displayed.
You really need better photographs to illustrate the point here. That second picture is one of the worst examples of a FiH I've seen; it's so loose and fat that you can hardly tell it apart from the Windsor.
Separate names with a comma.