Sin City

Of course it's comic book; it's based on a Frank Miller graphic novel (he did the Dark Knight series, fabulous stuff). koji

Sin City was excellent. I can only hope Batman Begins is as good.

Saw the trailer for that; looks promising. koji

Does it seem strange to anyone else that a bunch of grown men get together to discuss the merits of fine clothing and the like, and end up posting about comic books, and the movies that derive (or blatantly steal) from comic books? I guess it just goes to show you that Comics (and video games.) aren't really for kids anymore. Just a random thought. Anyone playing any video games right now?

AWESOME movie. have been a huge fan of the comics and i remember hearing about this being made into a movie several years ago so how stoked was i to see it finally realized?. the movie follows the comics nearly scene for scene, word for word. the most faithful translation of a comic into a movie that has been made so far. the casting was amazing, for the most part. nearly everybody looked just like their comic alter ego, even down to the lesser characters who dont have as much screen time. i was one of the few i know of who actually liked Sky Captain, and Sin City takes that bluescreen technique to its fullest but also has the added luxury of a GOOD script. i hope that this doesnt open a floodgate of films shot against bluescreen because in the wrong hands it could be a real disaster with all style, no substance. but for a film that evokes vintage/noir imagery/style, the bluescreen can be a hella effective way to film it. gotta see this again.

Going with the group here. I've always had a place in my heart for film noir. I loved the comic and I loved the movie. I have to see it again. I've heard an interview where Frank Miller and Robert Rodriguez said they'd like to do the other Sin City stories as movies and I, for one, can't wait until they do.

I thought this movie was great, and thought that the casting was great as well.

Rodriguez' best film since From Dusk Till Dawn, and perhaps his best ever. It was amazing visually, the casting was excellent, and the amount of sheer, uninhibited violence felt like a breath of fresh air from beginning to end. I loved it.

I thought from dusk till dawn was a good movie until the zombies showed up

I'm waiting for Sin City to hit the Netherlands, but once it does, I'm there. Kai, you really should read Miller's "The Dark Knight Returns", I think that it is possibly his finest work, along with "Batman Year One".... I've seen the trailers for the "Batman Begins", and I am not putting much hope in it as capturing the mood and feel of Miller and Mazucchelli's work. As for "300", I thouroughly enjoyed it, although Miller took liberties with some historical facts.

We don't get any mor maturer as we age. Instead, our toys get bigger and more expensive.

I've never read the graphic novels but I loved the movie. Wife and I have actually seen it twice.

Comic books haven't been for kids for years now. The stereotypical comic reader is the comic book guy on the Simpsons and the industry caters to him.