yea, crazy I know. I'm 5'8, 150 or so, fairly slim, but athletic build...and finding one that fits slimmer and shorter has been a challenge. the closest I've come to finding one that fits perfectly was actually a juicy couture one, out of all brands. it was a dressier, more structured peacoat that fit perfectly in the shoulders and length (b/c it was technically considered "cropped"). but the collar was huge and I like the option of having the collar down and up.