or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › I need more help with shoes
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I need more help with shoes

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
I currently own no shoes that are appropriate for wear with a suit. Part of the reason is that I've always thought my big feet look ridiculous in non-sneaker shoes. However, I've committed myself to finding a good pair, especially after my luck with these RLPL EGs on eBay (not suit-worthy, but they convinced me that my feet can look good in real shoes). I've concluded, thanks to an earlier discussion here, that a shoe with a tightly beveled waist and small welt will make my foot look most reasonable, as will a loafer with a short vamp. However, because I would like to wear these shoes with a suit, I've decided that loafers aren't my best bet. I don't want to spend too much, because I won't be wearing them that often. I was thinking something like this, which goes for around $375. I also like these, but I haven't tried them on and think they would be significantly more expensive. The first are Cole Haan Collection, which I've tried on and think they look decent. The second are Santoni, and I have no idea what they might look like on my foot. I also gather that brown is more versatile than black and acceptable in almost all the same occasions, but if I'm wrong please correct me. For reference, I've tried on Allen-Edmonds shoes but they all look huge on my feet; I need something sleeker. Any thoughts on these 2 shoes? Recommendations for what else I should be looking at? Thanks.
post #2 of 9
The first one is much more of a "fashion" shoe IMO. Notice the unsubtle stitching and the extra-long toe cap. The designer is obviously trying very hard (too hard, I think) to jazz-up a traditional cap-toe. The second, the Santoni, appears more timeless to me; plus, it has a somewhat pointy toe so as not to be as conservative as, say, an Allen Edmonds "Park Avenue" shoe.
post #3 of 9
The Cole Haan is disgusting, IMO. The Santoni is much better looking. Be careful though when going for an extended, chisel toe. While you are rise for avoiding Allen Edmonds because it might make your feet look too wide and therefore huge, the extended chisel toe can give you the opposite problem -- your foot looks sleek but overly long. IMO, you are better off going for something that doesn't have much of an outsole and that gradually becomes a square toe. The Edward Green 606 is the ideal, IMO. Compare how the 606 looks with how that Santoni looks. See the difference? That could be the difference between you looking like you have size 13 feet and looking like you have size 11 feet. (No offense to those with size 13 feet).
post #4 of 9
Thread Starter 
Any place online where I can look at the 606? Or I guess since you're in Boston, are there stores which carry both Santoni's and EGs? Thanks for both responses. I had a feeling the Cole Haans were a bit out there, but when I tried them on I really liked that they didn't make my feet seem wider than they already are. I see your point about the length though, and you're right. So what's one of these shoes going to cost me?
post #5 of 9
I don't know of anywhere in Boston that carries EG anymore. Saks certainly doesn't, and neither does NM here. But I don't mean for you to go out and buy EGs. Rather, look at the design of the last. Then find something that is in a more reasonable price range and choose accordingly. I think someone posted the EG catalogue here once. Don't remember who. Also, take a look at the Paul Stuart website. The Stuart's choice perf cap toe that is $625 strikes me as a virtual copy of the 606 last.
post #6 of 9
Call me, I will help., as much as possible.
post #7 of 9
Thread Starter 
The Paul Stuart perf cap toe looks great, just as I described. New York is the closest place I can try those on, right? Bennie, how late are you open? I will certainly call and take you up on your offer. Thanks.
post #8 of 9
Quote:
The Paul Stuart perf cap toe looks great, just as I described. New York is the closest place I can try those on, right? Bennie, how late are you open? I will certainly call and take you up on your offer. Thanks.
til 6
post #9 of 9
Quote:
The Stuart's choice perf cap toe that is $625 strikes me as a virtual copy of the 606 last.
It has a longer toe than the 606, closer to the 888 IMO. If you want to make your foot look smaller, a chisel toe that isn't too elongated will work. It's even more effective to buy pants with more width at the cuff. And best of all, just quit worrying how big your foot looks.. That's what I do
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › I need more help with shoes