I don't get a lot of criticism; I tend to get more compliments. At a dance last Saturday night I got several compliments on looking good, a nice tie, interesting pocket square, always dressing well, etc. and then a guy complimented me on the texture of my dress shirt. I got an eye-roll from a woman when I responded that it was just a simple twill weave. I guess guys aren't supposed to display too much knowledge. Edit: Although I try to dress well, I also try to dress appropriately for the occasion. So my standard casual dress is jeans with a jacket, OCBD, chelsea boots, and no tie, for example (always with a pocket square, though).