Originally Posted by Henry Boogers
I've worn the plain toes and the wingtips and I thought they were a little large. Heck, I could get through the day with a 10B on my 10.25D feet, so there you go....(I wouldn't recommend this, and subsequently sold the shoes after about a dozen wears).
I think vintage florsheims fit true for the most part, at least much more consistent than some of the international makers today.
There is some "wiggle room" on widths however, what I mean is that as a US 9.5D, I've been able to wear Es and Cs, and even 10 Bs and they all fit similarly.
In any case, I don't think they run large. They just have huge welts.