I thought the gant was a little more sought after than it seems to be so they'll probably go back in that case as they didn't quite fit. Their pockets are on the chest too which was a little weird tbh!
The J-Crew was mostly because of the collar. I was hoping to learn what the deal was. I've never seen a shirt like that before. Also, is it worth keeping the Harris tweed blazer in spite of the 2-3 holes like that?
Also, one of the RL pants was blue label with the italicized script :)
If you are buying for yourself, just buy what you like. Don't worry about what people here think. I would say that if you are buying for yourself, hold out for stuff that is clean and well-kept. No sense in buying yourself a shirt with stains. We've all got those already. Gant Rugger is a bit more sought after than their other stuff. I don't buy anything with holes in it, and the only way I think I'd break that rule is if it was a very very nice suit or jacket that would be worth the price of getting a re-weaver, and they are notoriously expensive. Something like 60-100 dollars per 5 or 10 MM.
Spoo says those RL pants are women's, and I'd trust him on that.