Well I will jump in real quick since we are talking about Tom James.
I received a few suits (actually a few x3, or was it? ) from them in a trade with a fellow member. What I can say about what I received is probably top tier. H&S cloth, in fact one of them is so freaking soft, I want to wear the suit naked. This feels like butter, and is so damn gorgeous. The reputable trader confirmed it feels nicer than a 14 micron Kiton. From what little research I did on a few of these items, I came to the conclusion that a few were from a bespoke line from TJ, not all MTM. Anyways, the quality is superb IMO from most stuff I've thrifted for myself. The fabric is top tier H&S. The drape is gorgeous, and the working button cuffs fit prefect
I'm not here to discuss why they are so good, or why they may be a waste of time. But for me, and what I received, FUCK YEA THEY ARE AWESOME! Holy freaking shit, I would trade for another dozen if I could!
Enjoy them if they are for your personal use, especially if the quality in construction and fabric is anything compared to what I received.
DISCLOSER: I'm only leaving the trader out of the convo because:
A. I doubt he / she cares.
B. He / she can chime in if they please.
C. I don't want to step on any toes or bring anyone into my convo w/o prior communication.