Quote:
Originally Posted by
MattR 
Usually, it's the shoulder pads. I agree that a lot of people can't tell the difference, but often I see guys wearing jackets as SC's, and the shoulders just look off.
So, I'm going to play the Thrift Fit Pic Game today. This is the Oxxford SC I picked up a few months ago. The tie is BB Makers from Mr. Floors to Go. If the waist looks a little tight, it is. Working on it.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
I love that this has become a thing!! Ok man, you're my NoVA peeps, so I'll give you my honest assessment:
I really like the jacket and shirt fits...some will say they're too tight, but I tend toward that anyhow. Yes, I can see what you're saying about the waist, but IMO it only needs to come out a teeeeeeeeensy bit more. I think a bit more work is needed on the lower half. I really can't put my finger on it, but for some reason I just don't like the way that those pants cuffs show up with those shoes. It's a strange thing to critique, and I can't put my finger on why it looks off to me, but it does. Maybe the colors are a bit odd or flushed out? IDK, but I'd like to see some other, possibly darker pants. I like the tie, but work on the dimpling!! I fully sympathize, as a dude who's new to dimpling and having a really tough time getting a Spoo-rific dimple out of my ties, but work the fabric a bit more to get a more even and deeper-sitting dimple. It looks super cool when done perfectly.
All told, I love the look. The Oxxford SC is definitely the scene stealer (as should come as no surprise). Also, the shirt sleeve length to jacket cuffs showing ratio is perfect. Perfect amount of shirt sleeves showing. LOVE that people are doing this as a thing and being brave souls and posting. Keep at it champs.
I wasn't planning on doing so, but you've inspired me, and I'll post yesterday's fit for me (I teleworked today
, so my fitpic would consist of destroyed jeans and my law school t-shirt). I'm actually pretty dissatisfied with it, which is part of the reason I didn't post it yesterday.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)


Suit: Brooks Brothers
Tie: Burberry
Shirt: Armani collezioni
Shoes: florsheim imperial wingtips in shell
My personal criticisms: Nothing wrong with it, it's just too boring. I don't like the way the shirt collar sits (Armani Collezioni), and the knot the tie (Burberry) ties ups. Good pattern, but the knot is too limp and dead for my taste.