Sorry, I know this has been asked before, at least once or twice, but what oil do you guys use for your CXL Indy boots? I use Obenauf's Leather Oil on my Wolverine 1Ks but that darkens them up too much. I don't mind messing with the Wolverines because I'm harder on those boots. I just need something to keep my Aldens conditioned and looking good while staying as close as possible to the original color. Any help is appreciated.
You did nothing wrong.
Some people say to use nothing except a brush from time to time.
Others have said to use Obenauf's HDLP.
Nick Horween says to use neatsfoot oil.
I know others suggest Montana pitch blend.
I have only used conditioner from time to time.