***The official Alden thread *** - Page 3895
Get the PTBs in #8s. It's the most versatile shoe they make. The "Swiss Army Knife" of shoes. I suppose if you must, the Chukka in #8 would work, but personally I can't trust a shoe that doesn't know if it's a boot or a shoe
I think both of those shoes can pull double duty. I think it may depend on the color also.
Probably can't tell the difference between PTB and Chukkas with your pant leg down! It just adds a little flair when you flash some ankle!
Since fall is coming up, I say chukka. Still extremely versatile.