Quote:
Originally Posted by
Bakes11771 
Uncle, Thank you.
Does anyone have experience buying multiple sizes for the same model shoe tree? (Woodlore, Jos. A, Allen Edmonds, Alden). I take a medium, but am wondering how much bigger a large is?
Is it a big difference? or a small difference?
The Mediums seem like they could stand to be bigger, but not drastically.
Thanks.
Yes.
Over the years I have had various trees in various sizes:
AE split toe - medium and large
AE full toe/JosABank full toe (same thing) - medium and large
Alden and BB (which are both split-toe and are substantially similar) - medium and large
So now, unless I have lasted shoe trees for some of my English shoes, I use almost exclusively:
AE full toe/JosABank full toe - medium
Alden and BB - large
All of my shoes would fall within the following US sizes: 9, 9.5, or 10.
I am one who generally prefers my trees to fill the entire toe box. Some don't really care about that, which is fine with me.