I know this has been discussed many times, but for those who have used shell cordovan shoes/boots in foul weather, what is your take on this Put This On article
suggesting that shell cordovan is particularly suited for foul weather? They seem to downplay the spotting effect many have observed.
Here is an excerpt:
Shell cordovan is also my material of choice for rainy day footwear. Some men worry that harsh elements will ruin their “precious” shell cordovans, but it’s important to remember that one of the material’s main advantages is its toughness. You can walk through hail, rain, sleet, or snow in these things and your feet will stay bone dry. Yes, this may cause the leather to rise a bit in some places, but you can smoothen it out by rubbing it with a deer bone (or simply the curved side of a metal spoon), and giving it a vigorous brushing. If you wish, you can also help protect the leather by applying a bit of wax polish once or twice a year (any more and shell cordovan won’t shine up well).