Not sure why I'm asking this here since the answer will almost always be shell, but here goes . . .
I'm trying to decide between Cigar PTB's with antique trim on the Barrie last like the one pictured below or the tobacco chamois CapToes on the Plaza last that were pictured here yesterday. I've never been a big fan of the PTB since it seems a bit chunky to me. The Captoe Plaza shoe should be a bit sleeker and I like the fact that it comes with a commando sole so I could wear it in rain or if there's ice on the ground (we don't get snow in Texas). But then the other shoes are cigar shell . . . hence my dilemma.