The first pair is from Unionmade, the Alpine Brown Longwings in grain leather.
The other pair is from J Crew, the Tobacco Longwings.
Does anybody have any experience and/or pictures with both of these colors? Are they different enough to justify keeping both?
I'll also add that I don't wear wingtips a lot. I mainly lean towards the indy boots for casual, and Alfred Sargent double monk straps or Alden cordovan boots for work/ formal occasions.