Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Streetwear and Denim › ***The official Alden thread *** Share enthusiasm, reviews, sizing, advice, and photos.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

***The official Alden thread *** Share enthusiasm, reviews, sizing, advice, and photos. - Page 5429  

post #81421 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReppTiePrepster View Post
 


Probably shape.  While the Marlow is definitely sleeker, the double leather sole makes the Marlow pretty darn chunky; it may not be a gunboat, but it is certainly tank-like.

Owning both, I feel like the Marlow is slightly more sleek, but not substantially. I think the shape of the toe and the short wing make it so. It is slightly more dressy looking to me, but since it is a blucher, it is still only "supposed" to be casual. 

Created with GIMP

post #81422 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReppTiePrepster View Post


Probably shape.  While the Marlow is definitely sleeker, the double leather sole makes the Marlow pretty darn chunky; it may not be a gunboat, but it is certainly tank-like.

Quote:
Originally Posted by bkotsko View Post

Owning both, I feel like the Marlow is slightly more sleek, but not substantially. I think the shape of the toe and the short wing make it so. It is slightly more dressy looking to me, but since it is a blucher, it is still only "supposed" to be casual.  Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
Created with GIMP

I would wear that bus. casual all day, everyday. I would probably not wear that with denim for some reason. Maybe the same reason for MrDV's statement.
post #81423 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by tifosi View Post

I would wear that bus. casual all day, everyday. I would probably not wear that with denim for some reason. Maybe the same reason for MrDV's statement.

I don't wear much denim at all, but I have worn both with denim (actually, I think all once both pictured here) and am cool with it...

 

post #81424 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReppTiePrepster View Post


Probably shape.  While the Marlow is definitely sleeker, the double leather sole makes the Marlow pretty darn chunky; it may not be a gunboat, but it is certainly tank-like.

Quote:
Originally Posted by tifosi View Post


I would wear that bus. casual all day, everyday. I would probably not wear that with denim for some reason. Maybe the same reason for MrDV's statement.

Keeping in mind most of us have more than one pair of shell shoes...
Yes. For me, the shape is the defining factor. The marlow is sleeker than the 975. I think that sleekness is more formal. The same is true for the 975, it's probably too clunky for a suit. But if I had too, for versatility purposes, I would dress up a 975 but couldn't dress down a marlow.
If I'm only packing 1 pair of nice shoes for a week long cruise. I can wear 975 to every "nice dinner" including the 2 dress up days, the marlow however would be too dressy for MY everyday wear.
Obviously, everyone should have and bring both.
post #81425 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by MrDV View Post


Keeping in mind most of us have more than one pair of shell shoes...
Yes. For me, the shape is the defining factor. The marlow is sleeker than the 975. I think that sleekness is more formal. The same is true for the 975, it's probably too clunky for a suit. But if I had too, for versatility purposes, I would dress up a 975 but couldn't dress down a marlow.
If I'm only packing 1 pair of nice shoes for a week long cruise. I can wear 975 to every "nice dinner" including the 2 dress up days, the marlow however would be too dressy for MY everyday wear.
Obviously, everyone should have and bring both.
Thanks for the explanation, MrDV. In that same cruise scenario, I would bring only the 975 as well.
post #81426 of 122416


They're both nice but I'm with DV Marlow is nice but too pointy and sleek for casual, I had to sell mine since they were not a good fit for me ,Barrie size too narrow and TTS the instep was too big needing insoles or tongue pads, I like the Marlow color better but the 975 is way more comfortable and a best fit for me., in the other hand the Marlow medallion and stiching is very nice better than Alden IMHO but shell finish is better on the Alden.

The Marlow is like a mix between a bal and a blucher.
post #81427 of 122416
^^ Nice comparison shot! DOn't think I've seen one of those yet. It really illustrates the shape.
post #81428 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by epc2 View Post



They're both nice but I'm with DV Marlow is nice but too pointy and sleek for casual, I had to sell mine since they were not a good fit for me ,Barrie size too narrow and TTS the instep was too big needing insoles or tongue pads, I like the Marlow color better but the 975 is way more comfortable and a best fit for me., in the other hand the Marlow medallion and stiching is very nice better than Alden IMHO but shell finish is better on the Alden.

The Marlow is like a mix between a bal and a blucher.

Here are a few other thoughts on the Marlow vs #8 LWB.

The refinements on the Marlow and slightly better, such as the tightness of the stitches or the finishing of the welt.

However, the Alden Shell Cordovan finishing is far superior. I actually don't love to wear my
Marlows because I know that I am going to spend more time caring for them after I wear them. When I brush them, they get "goose bumps" and I spend a lot of time hand buffing those out. A lot of people have stated that they do not brush their Marlows, but I am a big fan of brushing as it is the best way to getting the oils out of the Shell and keeping them looking pristine. I have read, at least for the Gianni, that paste wax helps with the "Goose Bumps", but I have yet to try it out. Alden puts an acrylic finish or something on their shoes that helps protect and stuff to their Shell Cordovan. This makes the Shell easier to care for (at least out of the box and for the first several years)...

As others have pointed out the Marlow is on a bit sleeker of a last, however, as I think RTP captured in his photos, it has an uber thick double sole. The 975 has on a more generous last "the Barrie" and looks a little more clunky. I combat this personally by getting it made on a narrower width. Most here size down in length on the Barrie, but I narrow it up personally. That makes it harder to get them in the store, but on standard shoes such as the 975 or 9751, you can just submit an order and the factory will run it for you. The Alden LWB has a double leather sole, but it is not as beastly as the Marlow. I personally find the brick of a sole on the Marlow to reduce from its sleekness.

Finally, another huge consideration is the color. #8 is the quintessential Shell Cordovan color, while the Dark Brown is not, but is still a lovely color.

I personally wear either up or down.

Finally, as I alluded to earlier, the 975 is readily available, but the Marlow is less consistent. The 975 can be made in a variety of widths, while the Marlow is only made in "D" widths (US standard width).

Just some thoughts, but I personally would go with the Alden 975 due to the fact that you have the Lindricks (and thus have the Brown Shortwing aspect covered, although in a boot) and due to the shell cordovan treatment. Good luck! Let us know how it turns out...

-Mike
post #81429 of 122416
^^Great post, dubs.

Just touching on something you said...I would love to size down a width on the Barrie, but I'm afraid my instep is too high. My D widths lace pretty far apart as it is (further apart than I have seen others on this thread). How much does sizing down on width really affect the width of the shoe across the instep? The Barrie has soooo much volume for me I wish I could reduce it.

I guess it really doesn't matter as I don't plan to sell what I have, but I guess more for conversation sake.
post #81430 of 122416
Things I always do in Honolulu.
1. Drinks at House Without a Key
2. Dinner at Alan Wong's.
3. Hit up Leather Soul.
post #81431 of 122416
Plaza Pitt boot??
post #81432 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by rydenfan View Post

Plaza Pitt boot??

I think these are LS Safari boots on Plaza.
post #81433 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by epc2 View Post

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

They're both nice but I'm with DV Marlow is nice but too pointy and sleek for casual, I had to sell mine since they were not a good fit for me ,Barrie size too narrow and TTS the instep was too big needing insoles or tongue pads, I like the Marlow color better but the 975 is way more comfortable and a best fit for me., in the other hand the Marlow medallion and stiching is very nice better than Alden IMHO but shell finish is better on the Alden.

The Marlow is like a mix between a bal and a blucher.

 

Great shot. I always thought Marlow was more close to cigar and the shape was close enough. I think I will stay with my 975. And yes, agree with most others here. The 975s have the best fit among all my Barrie shoes, and are by far the most comfortable for non-commando soles.

post #81434 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by zippyh View Post

Things I always do in Honolulu.
1. Drinks at House Without a Key
2. Dinner at Alan Wong's.
3. Hit up Leather Soul. Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

Those look very nice. Congrats! 

post #81435 of 122416
Quote:
Originally Posted by zippyh View Post

Things I always do in Honolulu.
1. Drinks at House Without a Key
2. Dinner at Alan Wong's.
3. Hit up Leather Soul. Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

Those look great! It's good to see plain toe snuff suede boots in the wild. I'm on the preorder for the Context snuff Roy boots and have been wondering how the plain toe + snuff + boot combo would look over time (the only snuff I've owned is a wingtip boot).
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Streetwear and Denim
This thread is locked  
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Streetwear and Denim › ***The official Alden thread *** Share enthusiasm, reviews, sizing, advice, and photos.