Cigar/whiskey/4 = antique
Color 8/black = dark
Ravello = indifferent, lean towards dark
Just putting it out there, other opinions likely vary.
I would suggest you may not be in the minority. Those that like antique with color 8 are vocal about it (which is totally fine - even a good thing); but I suspect those that don't care for it or don't prefer it remain for the most part silent. I don't dislike antique with color 8, but I certainly prefer dark. I do think there is near-unanimous agreement that antique makes for a more casual presentation. My 2 cents ...