Stretch or Sell?
Cigar 10D in Aberdeen. 10D in barrie and trubalance fit well to even slightly large. These are tight on the top, toes have a little wiggle room. My cobbler stretched some Allen Edmonds shells I have but wanted the expert's opinion before taking the plunge with these. Might be a catch and release. (sorry about the awful color combo, wasn't expecting to get these until tomorrow)
Your second photo doesn't look bad on the width. In the first photo, it does look like you have a higher instep that could be an issue with low vamp loafers. I don't know how much a cobbler could stretch a shell vamp.