I was hoping to get a little sizing advice after several frustrating experiences. I am trying to figure out the best size to order for a pair of shell split toe loafers in the Grant last. I just received a pair in 12C and although they're long enough, they seem too narrow. I have a pair of shell shortwings on the Tremont last that are 12D, but they are a bit roomy, which isn't as big of an issue since they are lace-ups. Any thoughts on whether I should just go true to size and order a 12D in the loafers on Grant last or if I should size down to the 11.D? Thanks!
This (bold) would seem to suggest 12D is the answer. Am I missing something?