After some trial and error, I've sold my shells and started fresh.
I currently have a LWB and LHS on the way. Both are #8. When I wear suits, I go with a black bal. I'd still like a boot, and I'm hesitant to get another color 8, but I never wear the black shoes I currently have. Cigar or ravello would be an option, except finding cigar seems to be on par with finding a unicorn or sasquatch.