If you are talking about the AF140... https://www.alden-of-carmel.com/Shoes-Brown_Wing_Tip_235.htm
I prefer the Innsbrook without question. For an all-purpose, weather-beater on commando, I'll take the chrmxl with the eyelets. I have that same brown calf LWB with double leather soles. It's a nice shoe that I have worn a great deal in its lifetime (4 years). But I reach for the Innsbrook MUCH more frequently now
Also, do you have pics of the brown calf LWB?