I'm the least partial to #3... I think it's not as good as the others.
I'm all for cuff but I think that the ebay vintage sleeves are a tad short. When wearing something like that (statement), it's got to fit very very well. Also, that pattern definately has the most character.
Length of the jacket is a tad short, but closer to where it should be as compared to the other three, which IMO are all a bit too long...
But my overall thoughts are they're all passable, not overly great or bad.
As for the tie, change it up to navy, burgandy rep, etc...