Going back to the original question, Talbott shirts are decent but nothing special. You probably have a number of options at BG. You could order Borrelli MTM, Charvet MTM, Geneva custom, Individualized MTM, Kiton MTM and maybe more. You could try Geneva or Paris directly. Another option could be to try one of the Gambert shirtmakers in New Jersey if you're in the area: http://www.gambert.com http://www.gambertshirts.com
Looking at some of the pictures on the second site, they don't seem to be very meticulous in matching patterns of the sleeve/sleeve placket.