I haven't been to either of them since I don't currently have a car and live about 30 minutes outside of Columbus, but in addition to Boris I hear Golden Needle is pretty quality as well, if they are open.
Edit: As for shoe sizes the number is the size, the letter is the width. Look for a sizing chart to see how they translate to UK and other sizing.
Edit: As for shoe sizes the number is the size, the letter is the width. Look for a sizing chart to see how they translate to UK and other sizing.













