Could you tell me the colors of pants you match it with and how you wear it? Casual evening dinner out? Daytime with jeans?
And did you consider the houndstooth? The one you have seems to have more subtle grey undertones to the brown and a different weave but a similar tone of brown.
I purchased the jacket at the Suitsupply store in Washington DC when I was there last month on business. I don't remember seeing the houndstooth.
I have worn it 4-5 times in the past month, both in the daytime and for casual evening events. Daytime with jeans would be fine, although I haven't done it yet. I've worn it with brown moleskin trousers, grey trousers, khakis, and tan trousers.
Don't forget that Suitsupply has free shipping and free return shipping. You can always order both jackets and keep the one you like more.